Navigating the Choice Between Specialist and Generalist Careers
Written on
In 2020, during the pandemic, I found solace in my hobbies: learning languages, painting, drawing, reading, and indulging in Korean dramas and anime.
One of my newfound favorites is the anime Demon Slayer, known as Kimetsu no Yaiba in Japanese. A quote from Zenitsu’s grandfather has recently resurfaced in my mind:
“That's perfectly fine. Celebrating mastery of even a single skill is worthwhile. If you can only manage one thing, strive to perfect it. Just as in sword-making, you must strike repeatedly to eliminate impurities. By refining the steel's purity, a strong sword emerges.”
Additionally, I came across a Bruce Lee quote in an article:
“I do not fear the man who has practiced 10,000 kicks once, but I fear the man who has practiced one kick 10,000 times.”
As someone focused on career growth, I often grapple with the significant choice between becoming a generalist or a specialist.
Honestly, I feel overwhelmed and uncertain about my next steps—whether to dive deep into one field or explore multiple interests.
While I have always believed that achieving expertise in a specific area is a commendable goal, I've also felt a persistent urge to experience various roles.
At times, I sense that I’m wandering aimlessly while others seem to have life figured out.
In contemplating the roles of specialists and generalists, I believe both have their merits; understanding this distinction can help set clear career objectives.
Specialist
According to the Cambridge Dictionary, a specialist is defined as:
- An individual with extensive experience, knowledge, or skills in a specific area.
- Someone who concentrates their studies or work on a particular subject, becoming an expert in that domain.
- A person who focuses more on one area of activity than others.
Specialists devote themselves to mastering a specific topic, often accumulating years of experience within their domain. For instance, a marketing specialist is an expert in a niche of marketing, such as social media or data-driven strategies. They leverage analytical skills to craft effective marketing initiatives and can lead marketing teams due to their expertise.
> “Every man gets a narrower and narrower field of knowledge in which he must be an expert in order to compete with other people. The specialist knows more and more about less and less and finally knows everything about nothing.” — Konrad Lorenz
The benefits of being a specialist are manifold. Firstly, it offers significant job security, as specialists are often in demand due to their expertise. Secondly, they typically command higher salaries, reflecting the value of their skills. Finally, their focus on a specific area allows for a greater sense of job satisfaction.
Generalist
A generalist, on the other hand, is characterized as:
- Someone who is not confined to a specialization.
- A person possessing a diverse skill set and knowledge base.
Generalists thrive on variety, engaging in numerous interests without necessarily excelling in any one area. The phrase “Jack of All Trades, master of none” aptly describes someone who has dabbed in many skills rather than achieving deep expertise.
> “Generalists have a more diverse collection of knowledge to draw from, so they can see connections and correlations that specialists might miss. They tend to have a higher EQ, too, because becoming a generalist means interacting with many different kinds of people in all sorts of situations.” — Paul Genberg
While generalists may not be experts, their broad skill set makes them adaptable in a rapidly evolving job market. They can approach problems from various perspectives, fostering innovative solutions that specialists might overlook. This adaptability offers flexibility, allowing generalists to transition into new roles, industries, or fields.
Early Specialization vs Late Specialization
In David Epstein's book Range: Why Generalists Triumph in a Specialized World, he discusses society's fixation on specialists, who often seem to have clear career trajectories.
What do you think? Although we recognize that each person’s journey is unique, the saying goes, “all roads lead to Rome.”
The book contrasts the education systems in the UK and Scotland. The UK emphasizes early specialization, encouraging students to focus on specific subjects early on. In contrast, Scotland promotes a broader exploration of interests before narrowing down career choices.
Fellexandro Ruby, an entrepreneur from Indonesia, surveyed individuals with linear career paths aligned with their college majors (early specialists) versus those with more varied paths (late specialists). The results showed a 30:70 ratio, suggesting that late specialists often outpace early specialists in skill development.
> “The early specializers start quitting their career tracks in much higher numbers, essentially because they were made to choose so early that they more often made poor choices. So the late specializers lose in the short term and win in the long run.” — David Epstein
Notable figures like Tiger Woods and Roger Federer exemplify this concept. Woods, who began playing golf at three, honed his craft early. Conversely, Federer explored various sports before committing to tennis.
Are You a Specialist or a Generalist?
Reflecting on these insights, I aspire to be an Expert-Generalist. Many successful individuals, like Elon Musk, have mastered multiple fields, transitioning from SpaceX to Tesla and beyond. Historically, philosophers were often polymaths, skilled in various disciplines.
> “An expert generalist is someone who has the ability and curiosity to master and collect expertise in many different disciplines, industries, skills, topics, and capabilities. It also means being able to draw on that diverse knowledge base to recognize patterns, connect dots, and improvise in situations.” — Orit Gadiesh
The key question isn’t which path is superior but which aligns best with our individual aspirations.
Epstein's book also highlights two problem types: Kind Problems and Wicked Problems.
Kind Problem: These problems are rigid with clear rules and predictable patterns, ideal for specialists to tackle.
For instance, in chess, it’s challenging for generalists to compete with seasoned specialists.
> “Like chess masters and firefighters, premodern villagers relied on things being the same tomorrow as they were yesterday. They were extremely well prepared for what they had experienced before, and extremely poorly equipped for everything else.” — David Epstein
Wicked Problem: These problems are irregular, unpredictable, and ever-changing. Generalists excel here due to their adaptability.
When considering which problems we’re better suited for, we must assess our capacities and inclinations.
In today’s complex landscape, the demand is often for expert-generalists who can navigate fast-evolving industries and anticipate future trends.
> “Modern work demands knowledge transfer: the ability to apply knowledge to new situations and different domains.” — David Epstein
For now, I identify as a generalist, eager to explore various fields without a clear specialization yet.
Choosing the path of a generalist may ultimately lead me to discover my niche. If you’re still searching for your passion, don’t be discouraged!
Whether you gravitate toward generalism or specialization depends on your career goals, interests, and the job market around you. Generalists offer versatility and adaptability, while specialists provide depth and focused expertise.
Ultimately, the choice is yours. Everyone has their own unique path to discover.
Finding your domain requires exploration and persistence—continuously trying new things until you find what resonates.
Regardless of the path you choose, committing to ongoing learning and personal development is crucial for success. Continuous improvement is the cornerstone of achievement.
> “The world needs specialists and highly trained people with advanced degrees, no question about it. But the world also needs diversity and versatility. It needs people who know as much about our value system as they do about our solar system.” — Roger Smith
References:
- Epstein, D. J. (2019). Range: Why Generalists Triumph in a Specialized World. New York, Riverhead Books.
© 2023 by Afiani Rui
Thank you for taking the time to read my story. I sincerely hope it resonated with you or brought you some joy. Please feel free to share your thoughts or feedback. Enjoy your reading!