The Enigmatic Mathematician Who Reshaped Mathematics
Written on
Chapter 1: The Birth of Bourbaki
Nicolas Bourbaki is a fascinating figure in the realm of mathematics—he never existed as an individual, yet his collective contributions have significantly impacted the field for more than eight decades. Bourbaki is credited with a variety of achievements, including a mock wedding for his daughter and an obituary upon his supposed passing, all contributing to his legendary status.
The aftermath of World War I left European academia in turmoil. Many scholars had been drafted into service, enduring disease and conflict. France faced a particularly harsh reality, with Aubin and Goldstein noting that "over 60% of science graduates from the 1910 class did not return from the front lines." This exodus left French academia in a state of disarray, affecting the growth and development of mathematics for a generation.
Section 1.1: The Struggles of Post-War Mathematics
The mathematical community faced a daunting task in rebuilding after the war. By the 1930s, the absence of coordinated efforts among mathematicians in France and beyond resulted in fragmented methods and terminologies, rendering the creation of new textbooks nearly impossible. Notably, no mathematics textbooks were published following Goursat's work in 1904. As Pieronkiewicz stated, there was a "noticeable impasse and increasing uncertainty surrounding the study of mathematics in France."
Jean Dieudonné remarked on this situation, noting, "This illustrated a spirit of democracy and patriotism we can only admire, yet the outcome was a dreadful loss of young French scientists."
Subsection 1.1.1: Forming a Collective
In light of these challenges, five mathematicians—Henri Cartan, Claude Chevalley, Jean Delsarte, André Weil, and Jean Dieudonné—came together to not only mend the fractured community but also to establish a curriculum for the next two decades. They unwittingly initiated a multi-generational effort to rethink the foundations of mathematics, both invigorating and irritating their peers.
They humorously named their collective after Charles-Denis Bourbaki, a French general known for his failures during the Franco-Prussian War. The name Nicolas is thought by some to reference St. Nicolas, perhaps indicating the group's intention to provide valuable contributions to the struggling mathematical landscape.
Chapter 2: The First Bourbaki Conference
The founding members, along with René de Possel, convened at Café Grill-Room A. Capoulade, a quaint spot in Paris' Latin Quarter. Their initial task was to refine the application of Stokes' theorem, a key component in higher-dimensional calculus that had fallen out of favor in France. Over a hearty meal of cabbage soup and grilled meats, they agreed to work collaboratively, hold regular meetings, and include the work of mathematicians from other countries, particularly Germany.
In July 1935, the inaugural Bourbaki conference was held, attended by three prominent French mathematicians. It was at this gathering that they collectively decided to publish their findings under the Bourbaki name and broaden their scope to include areas such as topology, set theory, abstract algebra, and Lie groups. Rather than inventing new mathematics, Bourbaki aimed to streamline, organize, and refine existing knowledge, establishing a coherent set of axioms upon which all mathematics could rely.
The video title is "How Imaginary Numbers Were Invented." This video delves into the intriguing history of imaginary numbers, exploring their origin and significance in mathematics.
Section 2.1: The Impact of Bourbaki
Jean Dieudonné stated that "What Bourbaki has accomplished is to define and generalize a concept that had been prevalent for a long time." Following this meeting, Possel's wife humorously baptized Nicolas Bourbaki, allowing the group to publish articles under this pseudonym. Their first submission, "Sur un théorème de Carathéodory et la mesure dans les espaces topologiques," was swiftly accepted by the mathematical community.
Within a few years, Bourbaki conferences took place three times a year, attracting some of the continent's leading mathematicians. Attendees often left these spirited gatherings with the impression of being part of a "gathering of madmen." Dieudonné noted that the meetings had no formal structure, and it was common for members to harshly critique one another's ideas, regardless of their ages or experience.
The only formal regulation dictated that members retire by age 50, based on the belief that older mathematicians might struggle to adapt to new methodologies. This dynamic resulted in the creation of a vast body of work, culminating in the 1939 publication of Éléments de mathématique. Over the ensuing decades, this collection became essential reading, expanding to twelve volumes and 6,000 pages, with the latest edition released in 2016.
However, the German invasion of France in 1940 severely hindered their progress, with some members joining the military and others fleeing from Nazi persecution, once again placing French mathematics on shaky ground.
Chapter 3: Resurgence and Lasting Influence
Fortunately, Bourbaki resumed its conferences shortly after France's liberation in August 1944, and over the next 75 years, the group transformed the landscape of mathematics. Their insistence on rigor over speculation drew criticism, with some arguing that Bourbaki sterilized mathematical research. They prioritized logical consistency, establishing foundational principles and reformulating various mathematical fields.
For instance, they redefined functions, a core concept in mathematics. Traditionally viewed as machines that produce outputs based on given inputs, Bourbaki conceptualized functions as connections between two sets, enabling the identification of logical relationships. They categorized functions into three types: injective, surjective, and bijective. Through precise definitions like these, they constructed a more robust mathematical foundation.
Bourbaki also sought to simplify mathematical language, opting for clear and accessible terminology. They replaced complex Latin and Greek terms with more straightforward alternatives, preferring "paving stones" over "parallelotopes" and "balls" instead of "hyperspheroids." As Jean Dieudonné noted, "We believe that ink is inexpensive enough to warrant writing things out fully, using a carefully chosen vocabulary."
Additionally, they introduced new symbols, such as the empty set, which remain widely used today. Overall, Bourbaki aimed to establish a logical foundation for all of mathematics, with Dieudonné describing this foundation as "a center from which all the rest unfolds."
Bourbaki's legacy extends far beyond their initial intentions. Their methods continue to shape modern mathematics, while their terminology and symbols remain in use. Éléments de mathématique endures, and their influence reaches into fields such as philosophy, psychology, and anthropology. Notably, Bourbaki's work laid the groundwork for structuralism, a movement advocating for the reduction of disciplines to their fundamental elements.
Jean Dieudonné likened mathematics to "a ball of wool, a tangled hank," asserting that even a minor change could impact the entire structure. Little did he realize in 1968 that the "ball" was far larger, with Bourbaki's influence permeating all realms of academia.
Quite impressive for a fictional mathematician.