Understanding Empathy: Sherry Turkle on Machines and Humanity
Written on
Chapter 1: The Intersection of Technology and Human Experience
In 1976, Sherry Turkle joined the faculty at MIT, contributing to one of the nation's pioneering programs in Science, Technology, and Society. With a background in French psychoanalysis and an interest in the cultural dynamics that influence our thoughts, she was intrigued by how computers would reshape our existence.
For the past four decades, Turkle has rigorously examined this pivotal question. As the founder of the MIT Initiative on Technology and Self, she has penned influential works, including The Second Self and Alone Together. Her research highlights the transformative nature of online identities and serves as a cautionary tale about how we risk becoming mere objects in our interactions with machines.
In her memoir, The Empathy Diaries, Turkle shares her deeply personal journey, illustrating how her experiences have shaped her views on empathy and technology. After her mother remarried, she was instructed to adopt her stepfather's surname, Turkle, while concealing her biological father's name. This secrecy instilled in her the importance of identity and the repercussions of a lack of empathy. “I had to learn to empathize with my family members to understand their motivations,” she reflects. “Empathy became a matter of survival.”
Turkle recently spoke with OneZero about her lifelong quest to grasp her roots, her experiences as a woman at MIT in the 1970s, and her skepticism regarding the efficacy of robo-therapists.
Section 1.1: The Relationship Between Psychoanalysis and Technology
OneZero: How did your background in psychoanalysis relate to your work in technology?
Sherry Turkle: At MIT, discussions revolved around cognitive science and artificial intelligence. They were excited about my ability to blend questions of the mind with technology. However, I noticed something they overlooked: people were developing emotional attachments to their computers. My focus shifted to how this new technology would profoundly affect our perceptions of humanity and our interactions with machines.
...This paragraph will result in an indented block of text, typically used for quoting other text.
Subsection 1.1.1: The Evolution of the Mind-Machine Paradigm
The early models of a mechanistic mind were simplistic. The debate then was whether we viewed the mind as a machine or a repository of meaning. Today, however, the collaboration between AI and neuroscience offers a more nuanced understanding of our mental processes. We cycle through models of the mind faster than ever, raising questions about the nature of consciousness and identity.
Section 1.2: The Burden of Identity and Empathy
Turkle's personal struggles with identity profoundly impacted her life. For years, she concealed the truth about her father, leading to feelings of shame and isolation. “As a child, I sensed the taboo surrounding my real name. I felt that if I revealed it, I would only worsen the situation,” she explains. Her relationship with her mother was complicated by anger and resentment, revealing how identity shapes our emotional connections.
Chapter 2: The Rise of Robo-Therapists and the Future of Empathy
The first video titled Can AI Ever Truly Understand Human Emotions? (This Is INSANE) explores the limitations of AI in grasping human emotional depth and the implications for our relationships with machines.
Turkle emphasizes that while AI can assist in certain tasks, it lacks the capacity to understand human emotions fully. “I can discuss my mortgage with a robot, but when it comes to sharing my fears and loneliness, I need someone who has experienced life,” she asserts.
The second video, Sympathy for the Machine, delves into the ethical concerns surrounding the use of AI in emotional contexts, questioning whether machines can ever truly empathize with human experiences.
Turkle warns against the dangers of treating humans as mere objects in an increasingly automated world. “We must not lose sight of what truly benefits people,” she cautions, pointing out the ethical pitfalls of prioritizing AI capabilities over genuine human connection.
In her view, empathy is a uniquely human trait, rooted in vulnerability and the ability to listen actively. “Empathy is not simply about understanding another's feelings; it requires a commitment to be present for them,” she explains. The current trend of relying on screens for communication diminishes our capacity for empathy, as it allows us to hide from one another.
In the fall of 1984, Turkle faced professional challenges at MIT when denied tenure. She recognized gender disparities in treatment and vowed to raise awareness about such injustices. “I realized I had been invisible in many ways,” she reflects. This experience propelled her to advocate for women's visibility and success in tech and science.
As society grapples with the questions Turkle raised nearly 50 years ago, she remains at the forefront of the conversation, urging us to confront the complexities of technology's impact on our humanity. Her journey illustrates the importance of empathy in an increasingly digital world.