The return of Doc Ock in Spider-Man: No Way Home showcases his relentless pursuit of harnessing solar power. His initial appearance in Spider-Man 2 (2004) featured his ambitious fusion device, which aimed to merge tritium nuclei to release energy. Experts in the scientific community, however, emphasize that achieving nuclear fusion is far more complex than cinematic portrayals suggest. Extensive global research is currently underway to tackle the numerous hurdles associated with this technology.

At present, nuclear fusion for energy production is an evolving field. The fusion reactors shown in films like Spider-Man 2 and Iron Man are significantly smaller and less intricate compared to those under current investigation. The goal of this research is to establish a stable, self-sustaining fusion reaction that produces more energy than it consumes, a feat that current models have yet to accomplish.

The process of fusing atomic nuclei demands extreme temperatures, high plasma density, and the ability to maintain proximity between nuclei long enough for interaction. The challenge lies in overcoming the repulsive forces between positively charged nuclei. While fusion occurs naturally in the Sun at millions of degrees Celsius under immense pressure, replicating such conditions on Earth requires even higher temperatures. This leads to the creation of a superheated plasma—a mix of nuclei and electrons. To facilitate fusion, the plasma must be confined using methods like lasers or magnetic fields; the latter is predominantly employed in research reactors. These magnets are cooled to near absolute zero, creating an immense temperature gradient that is unique in the universe. The true difficulty, however, lies in maintaining the nuclear reaction.

Currently, researchers must continuously supply heat to the reactor, preventing it from being self-sustaining. They also need to source tritium for each fusion attempt. Although Doc Ock suggested that harmonics could enable a self-sustaining reaction, it is more plausible that a viable fusion device will rely on another nuclear reaction. Combining tritium with deuterium releases energetic neutrons, and incorporating lithium into the reactor walls can generate more tritium, as lithium absorbs neutrons and undergoes fission. However, this remains theoretical, as existing reactors do not function this way.

Numerous Challenges Remain for Fusion Device Viability

The reactor's design significantly impacts the control of the fusion reaction, leading to various configurations in development. Unlike the compact reactors seen in films, real-life models are bulky and constructed from diverse materials, which can create structural vulnerabilities at the joints between these different substances.

The neutrons produced during fusion present further challenges for materials science. These high-energy neutrons (14 MeV) can penetrate and potentially damage reactor materials. They may also be absorbed by atoms within these materials, causing them to transmute into different elements or become radioactive. Researchers are actively seeking materials that can endure the extreme conditions within the reactor while minimizing neutron absorption to limit radioactivity. Nonetheless, some radioactive waste will likely be generated, classified as Low Level Waste, necessitating a management strategy.

Moreover, materials science faces additional hurdles. The helium generated from fusion can infiltrate reactor walls, creating bubbles that alter material properties. In some components, tungsten is used, and helium can react with it to create unusual surface structures. These formations pose risks of erosion, which could contaminate the plasma and destabilize the fusion process. Fortunately, any instability would not result in dramatic failures akin to those depicted in Spider-Man 2; rather, the reaction would simply diminish.

Doc Ock often refers to "precious tritium." This helium isotope is scarce in nature and has a short half-life of just over 12 years. The primary source of tritium comes from the nuclear industry, specifically CANDU reactors that generate electricity via nuclear fission. Neutrons from fission reactions are absorbed by deuterium in coolant water, converting it to tritium. If the theoretical method of producing tritium from lithium in fusion reactors proves unfeasible, the availability of tritium will remain limited unless we continue to utilize nuclear fission technology.

Advancements and Benefits of Fusion Research

In Spider-Man: No Way Home, Tony Stark's arc reactor was also portrayed as a fusion device, evolving throughout the Iron Man series. While the arc reactor is fictional, it serves to illustrate the size differences between Doc Ock's larger invention and contemporary experimental fusion devices. Most fusion reactors require near absolute zero cooling, but companies such as Tokamak Energy in the UK and a collaboration between Commonwealth Fusion Systems and MIT in the USA are innovating magnets that function at higher temperatures. This advancement not only conserves energy but also allows for more compact reactor designs.

As with other technologies involving radioactive materials, remote operation is crucial in fusion research. Robotic arms are often employed to navigate extreme conditions like radiation, differing significantly from Doc Ock’s specialized arms for tritium handling. The fusion sector is keen on leveraging advancements in robotics, sometimes driving innovations in that industry.

Scientific breakthroughs and technological advancements within the fusion sector have also spurred developments across various fields. For instance, the tungsten-helium structures that pose problems for fusion might find utility in photocatalysis or solar panel technology. What presents challenges in fusion could prove beneficial in other applications, underscoring the broader societal value of this demanding research.

Is Nuclear Fusion the Ultimate Solution to Energy Poverty?

Given the significant amount of research required to achieve a self-sustaining nuclear fusion reactor, this goal seems unlikely in the near future. At the beginning of 2022, a record was set for the longest fusion reaction lasting 17 minutes, yet this was not a net positive as it consumed more energy than it generated. The fusion industry remains far from realizing commercial electricity production, especially while more accessible energy sources continue to improve.

A common jest suggests that practical electricity generation from nuclear fusion is perpetually "30 years away." This may stem from a history of insufficient investment to tackle technical challenges. However, recent years have seen a surge in funding aimed at addressing these issues, with frequent announcements of breakthroughs. International collaborations are becoming increasingly prevalent in fusion research, raising hopes that these investments could finally dispel the longstanding joke.

Ultimately, cinematic portrayals of fusion often miss the mark. For example, the miniature sun created by Doc Ock is a fictional exaggeration; in reality, plasma typically appears purple in images. While the 2004 film is not the first in the Spider-Man series, earlier adaptations, such as the 1970s TV movies, may have better conveyed some nuclear science concepts. The latest trilogy, however, embraces a more humorous tone, making it a unique blend of science and entertainment that resonates with audiences—including scientists and theoretical physicists alike.

About This Story

This article is derived from a conversation featured on the podcast Technically Speaking, which delves into science and engineering discussions. The podcast recreates the quirky conversations scientists and engineers often have in the lab, blending scientific fact with creative speculation and numerous film references. New episodes are released biweekly and are available on platforms like Apple, Spotify, Amazon Music, Google, Podbean, and more.

You can follow the podcast on Twitter to continue the discussion.

To support this blog and podcast, consider becoming a Medium member for $5 (USD) per month. Signing up through my link will help fund the podcast, and you'll gain unlimited access to all Medium stories. Your support would be greatly appreciated!